Ethical dilemma on gay marriage

Genesis 19 suggests that Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed because of homosexuality, as does Jude 7. The motion calling on Parliamentarians to canvass their constituents on same-sex marriage noted "a growing list of countries that allow same-sex couples to marry including the Netherlands, Belgium, Norway, Spain, Canada and South Africa.

It is a matter of determining what best promotes human flourishing. Natural Law Despite the flaws here identified, Miller is to be commended for bringing into discussion three major traditions of ethical thinking "that have been developed over the last 2, years.

So too, virtue ethics would have traditionally regarded a person who treated like cases alike and different cases differently as just and virtuousbut the person who treated all cases alike as unjust and vicious.

Marriage goes beyond the benefits, however. According to this long tradition, which includes ancient Greek and Roman pagans Socrates, Plato, Aristotle and Cicero, to name a fewearly Jewish and Christian believers the prophets of Israel through to Augustine and Thomas Aquinas and other contemporary practitioners like John FinnisRobert P.

A virtuous person is a good person. I find it entirely illogical why, in this country, we still do not recognise a marriage between two people if those people are both of the same sex. The one biological function for which individual adults are naturally incomplete is sexual reproduction.

In March, Michigan decided that same-sex marriages were legal, then later the same day, that ruling was stayed, and then finally, later the same month, a federal appeals court stayed the ruling indefinitely Egan, It is for that reason that the State is involved with legislating to ensure the identity and status of children.

It is important to note that the federal law in Australia has already been changed to give same-sex partners the same legal rights as those who are married and in an increasing number of states to register their unions.

Changing the law so that marriage includes same-sex unions would be a change to what marriage means. Are gays made, or are they born.

Endorsing same-sex marriage would mean cutting some remaining but most important threads. If they receive a license of any kind in one state, it is upheld in the others as well.

Usually relegated to first year undergraduate classrooms, it was refreshing to see The Conversation feature an article last week bringing these three diverse and fascinating traditions of moral reflection into conversation about an issue everyone is talking about - same-sex marriage.

He reasons that if society allows unnatural homosexual relationships, there could be detrimental consequences for the next generation because the focus of society would be on personal pleasure instead of long-term benefit.

Is Ethics Wedded to Same-Sex Marriage?

As for other kinds of discrimination, these things already happen regardless of the fact that it has not been proven that homosexuality is determined by genetics. We ought to deal fairly with every member of the human family and their needs, including people of homosexual orientation.

These arguments are not negated by marriage breakdown, the early death of a parent, the adoption of children, de facto relationships, or the practice of step-parenting. Those who praise DOMA believe that it keeps children from growing up and thinking that being homosexual is okay. Watson, Traci, and Joseph P.

Ethics and Law/ Gay-Marriages term paper 17589

Everything turns on the woman who gives birth and her relationships and those whom she appoints to be the substitute parents. Now they are protected and our society no longer has to deal with those who find it unethical.

Is Ethics Wedded to Same-Sex Marriage?

Over half a century ago, in Nazi Germany, Hitler attempted to make the "master race". The Ethics of Same-Sex Marriage.

Leviticus suggests that gay homosexual sex is so egregious, that offenders should be killed if they are caught. abomination; they shall surely be put to death; their blood is upon them.” So, according to those that look at the ethical world with a theological voluntarism approach, same- sex.

Ethical Dilemma Same-Sex Marriage By: Deja McGill, John Jessup and Elora Hall Did you know.?

Ethical arguments against same-sex marriage laws

Massachusetts was the first state to legalize Gay marriage. An Ethics for Same-Sex Marriage. Thomas J. Mathews. Presented at the 19th Annual Affirmation Conference, August 23,Salt Lake City, Utah. A version of this paper was presented at the Sunstone Symposium, August The term “gay marriage”, to me, doesn’t sit right.

We don’t have gay breakfast, or go on a gay road trip in the same way we don’t play straight tennis or go sexually-diverse camping. It. Gay marriage should not be the ethical question.

the idea of marriage should be the ethical question. Is the binding generally contractual between 2 people an ethical practice? If a contract is required the relationship should be questioned as ethical. Ethical Dilemma Same-Sex Marriage By: Deja McGill, John Jessup and Elora Hall Did you know.?

Massachusetts was the first state to legalize Gay marriage.

Ethical arguments against same-sex marriage laws Ethical dilemma on gay marriage
Rated 3/5 based on 97 review
Is Ethics Wedded to Same-Sex Marriage? - ABC Religion & Ethics